What Should We Censor on the Web

There’s a huge debate online about the future of the internet.  In it’s infancy one of the most important concepts about the web was that it was completely open and not controlled by any single power.  In those early days that was pretty much fine, whilst a few of us connected using our 14.4k modems and used geeky tools like Archie, Gophur and Telnet to navigate our way around the various web sites that were available.

But those days have long gone now, the web is big business and is much easier to use.  Sit a toddler down at an online computer and point them at a games web page and pretty soon they’ll be surfing aways around the internet whilst playing Pacman in a minimized window.   The web is not truly global and for many has become an intrinsic part of our every day lives.

But this of course makes people nervous, the web is not always used for nice stuff.  Sure you can do your online banking and search for the cheapest utility prices, whilst chatting to your friends.  But bad people also use the web – criminals, thieves, hackers and paedophiles all have their own online communities.  You can visit web sites were people openly buy and sell stolen credit and debit cards, all hosted in some far off land where the police will happily turn a blind eye.  The bad guys love the web too.

In countries like China and Iran, the ruling powers are also not overly keen on the ’free speech’ element it allows.  Places like this already have a heavily filtered and censored version of the internet, the authorities blocking access to discussions and topics they’d rather you not view.  The reality is that in countries like this, someone else has control about what you can do online.

In Iceland for example the ruling government has decided that they don’t want people to acccess pornography online, you can read here about their efforts.  You might agree with this stance, however again it is allowing a government to decide what ordinary people should be allowed to use the web for.  Remember governments come and go, each one with different ideologies and beliefs.  Is the next Government going to be religious and ban all access to gay or atheists sites for example.

Also Available on YouTube – Online Privacy.

There are of course some serious technical difficulties with controlling access to something as widely distributed as the internet.  Many believe that it is actually technically impossible for any one nation to control all access without blocking the internet completely and replacing it.  It is why such filtering that the Icelandic Government are contemplating is such a bad idea.  People who want to download such items will simply use proxies and VPNs to download their pornography, including the criminal stuff.  In effect you’ll only censor the people who don’t mind being censored, all the while slowing down access for everyone.

We all have our own opinions on these issues, but whatever yours it’s worth getting involved with the debate.  All countries are considering their options so make sure your opinions get heard is filtering is to be implemented at an ISP near you.

Video article on Obtaining a Fake IP Address.